The DSM-5-TR diagnostic criteria - The international reference
The DSM-5-TR is the diagnostic manual of the American Psychiatric Association. It is the reference used by child psychiatrists and neuropaediatricians in Morocco to diagnose Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). Only a trained doctor can use it.
Autism Spectrum Disorder 299.00 (F84.0) - Full criteria
For an ASD diagnosis to be made, criteria A, B, C, D and E must ALL be met.
CRITERION A: Persistent deficits in communication and social interaction
Deficits present in various contexts, currently or in the past. All 3 sub-criteria below are required:
A1. Deficit in social and emotional reciprocity.
Ranging, for example, from:
- Abnormal social approach, difficulty starting or responding to an interaction
- Difficulty sharing interests and emotions, having a two-way exchange
- Inability to start or respond to a conversation
In concrete terms in a child: Does not come to show his drawing out of pride, does not share his enjoyment, talks but does not converse.
A2. Deficit in nonverbal communication behaviours used for social interaction.
Ranging, for example, from:
- Poorly integrated verbal and nonverbal communication
- Abnormal or absent eye contact and body language
- Difficulty understanding and using gestures and facial expressions
- Total lack of facial expressions suited to the context
In concrete terms: A gaze that avoids or that pierces, a smile that does not come at the same time as the words, few gestures used to accompany speech.
A3. Deficit in developing, maintaining and understanding relationships.
Ranging, for example, from:
- Difficulty adjusting behaviour to different social contexts
- Difficulty sharing imaginative play or making friends
- Absence of interest in peers
In concrete terms: Plays beside but not with, does not understand the unwritten rules of the playground, friendships centred only on his specific interest.
CRITERION B: Restricted and repetitive patterns of behaviour, interests or activities
At least 2 of the following 4 sub-criteria are required, currently or in the past:
B1. Stereotyped or repetitive movements, use of objects or speech.
- Simple motor stereotypies: hand flapping, rocking, spinning, toe walking
- Repetitive use of objects: lining up, spinning wheels, opening/closing
- Echolalia: repeating phrases heard, speaking in an idiosyncratic way, with atypical prosody
B2. Intolerance of change, inflexible adherence to routines or ritualised behaviour.
- Extreme distress at a small change: another route, another chair, another glass
- Difficulty managing transitions
- Rigid verbal or nonverbal rituals: always asking the same question, eating foods in the same order
- Rigid thinking
B3. Very restricted and fixed interests, abnormal in intensity or content.
- Excessive attachment to or preoccupation with unusual objects
- Circumscribed and persistent interests: exclusive passion for vacuum cleaners, train timetables, dinosaurs with an extreme level of detail
B4. Hyper- or hypo-reactivity to sensory input or unusual interest in sensory aspects of the environment.
- Apparent indifference to pain, temperature
- Negative reactions to sounds, textures: covering ears, refusing clothes, eating only certain textures
- Excessive sniffing or touching of objects, fascination with lights or spinning objects
This is the criterion added in 2013 that changed the lives of thousands of families. At last, sensory processing was recognised.
CRITERIA C, D, E: The essential conditions
C. Symptoms must be present from early childhood.
Even if they may only become fully apparent when social demands exceed abilities. So at 4 years old we can diagnose signs that were there at 18 months but compensated for by the parents.
D. Symptoms cause clinically significant impairment in functioning.
They limit independence, schooling, social and family life.
E. These disturbances are not better explained by an intellectual disability or global developmental delay.
Warning: Intellectual disability and ASD can coexist. To diagnose ASD in a person with an intellectual disability, social communication must be below what is expected for his or her general level of development.
The mandatory specifiers to add to the diagnosis
The DSM-5 does not stop at "autistic or not". The doctor must specify 4 elements. Demand them on the report:
- With or without associated intellectual impairment
- With or without associated language impairment
- Associated with a known medical, genetic or environmental condition - e.g. Fragile X syndrome, valproate exposure
- Current severity level:
| Level | Social communication | Restricted and repetitive behaviours | Support needed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Level 3: Very substantial support required | Severe deficits, very few social initiatives, minimal response | Extreme inflexibility, great distress at change, major interference in all areas | Very substantial |
| Level 2: Substantial support required | Marked deficits, Interactions limited to restricted interests, Atypical communication | Difficulty coping with change that is visible to others | Substantial |
| Level 1: Support required | Difficulty starting interactions, atypical responses, seems to lack interest in others, but can communicate with support | Inflexibility that interferes in one context, difficulty switching between activities | Required |
Essential note This level is NOT fixed. It describes the need for support AT THE TIME of diagnosis. A Level 2 child at 3 years old can move to Level 1 at 7 with suitable support. And conversely, a Level 1 without support can move to Level 2 in adolescence when social demands increase.
